Tax Appeal to the Office of Dispute Resolution
The Office of Dispute Resolution (ODR) is an independent adjudicatory body, separate from the other divisions but still within the Department of Revenue. If you disagree with the Department’s decision after your informal review, you can appeal to ODR. Although ODR administrative law judges (ALJs) and staff are Department employees, the ALJs are required by law to operate as impartial decision makers.
Confirm You're Eligible to File
- You may only appeal to ODR after completing an informal review and receiving a Final Determination Letter that states you have appeal rights with the Office of Dispute Resolution.
- Cannabis and Alcohol Regulatory Division (CARD) appeals follow a different procedure.
- Property tax appeals (excluding centrally assessed property) must be filed with the Property Assessment Division (PAD).
Don't Miss Your Filing Deadline
Your deadline runs from the issue date on your Final Determination Letter. You must file your appeal within:
- 45 days
- 15 days for centrally assessed property
You do not need supporting documentation to file your appeal. You can submit documents later. Do not delay filing to gather documentation.
What if I've missed the deadline?
If your deadline has already passed, you may still file; the judge will first determine whether you had reasonable cause for the late filing. If the ALJ finds you had reasonable cause, your appeal may then proceed on the substantive or underlying issue.
How to File Your Appeal
- Choose the form for your tax type.
- Fill it out. You'll need:
- Your Final Determination Letter
- Your Montana Account ID Number
- Your contact information including phone and email
- The tax years and tax types in dispute
- The date of the determination you're appealing
- Send it by email to dordisputeresolution@mt.gov, or by mail to:
Montana Department of Revenue
PO Box 5805
Helena, MT 59604-5805 - Filing on behalf of a taxpayer? Attorneys must file a Notice of Appearance with the appeal. Any other representative (such as a CPA or tax preparer) must file a signed Power of Attorney (PDF) with the appeal. The federal tax POA form is also accepted.
After You File
-
Watch for correspondence from ODR. Within about two weeks, you will receive scheduling details about your initial conference. The conference is procedural and you will not be asked to present evidence or make arguments.
-
At the initial conference, you and the ALJ will discuss the following options for proceeding on appeal:
- Informal Resolution: If both sides agree that the matter may be resolved through informal negotiations between the parties, the ALJ may stay the appeal for a period of time.
- Mediation: If both parties are in agreement, ODR offers mediation, a facilitated, informal discussion which may result in resolution.
- Hearing: The hearing is a formal, recorded proceeding in which the ALJ considers evidence and testimony submitted by the parties, applies the law to the facts, and issues a written decision.
- If you disagree with the decision, you can appeal to the Montana Tax Appeal Board within 30 days.
Interest and Penalties Continue During Your Appeal
Interest and penalties continue to accrue until the tax is paid in full, even while you appeal. You may pay the assessed amount in full to stop further accrual. Paying does not waive your appeal rights.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. You may represent yourself, or you may designate another individual such as a tax preparer to represent you, as long as they file a signed Power of Attorney (PDF) with ODR.
Yes, but the case will first be limited to whether your appeal was late for a good reason. The ALJ applies the “reasonable cause” standard in ARM 42.2.512. If the judge finds you had reasonable cause for filing late, your appeal proceeds to the merits of your case.
You can contact the ODR court clerk with procedural questions about the appeal process. The clerk cannot discuss the substance of your case (for example, how to support your argument, what information to introduce at hearing, how the judge might rule, etc.).
It depends on the complexity of the issues on appeal, the caseload of the court, and the path(s) the parties take. There is a 180-day statutory deadline for resolution that applies to all tax appeals, upon which ODR’s jurisdiction expires. However, you may choose to waive this deadline if you want the case to remain before ODR.
No. ODR ALJS are required by law to act as impartial decision makers. The ALJs and court clerk do not discuss appeals with other Department of Revenue employees or disclose information about tax appeals. Although ODR ALJs and staff are technically Department employees, the office acts as a separate, neutral, adjudicatory body. The ALJs function independently and make their determinations based on the controlling statutes and rules, as applied to the facts in each appeal.
When you file an appeal, the Division in which your tax dispute originated is required to file an informational memo with basic information about the issues in dispute, the tax years involved, and contact details so ODR can schedule the initial conference. If you have questions or concerns about it, you may raise them at the initial conference.
Mediation is a voluntary, confidential process where a neutral third party helps you and the Department work toward a settlement. It is an option if both parties agree to it. Learn more on the mediation page.